Skip to main content

How to Fix a Failed Payment

Find failed charges in Transaction Errors, get a working card or bank account on file, apply it to the student's memberships, and collect the missed payment.

Written by Ben Ryoo

When a membership charge fails, NextKick tells the family and retries card payments on its own. This guide shows where to see failed charges, how to get a working card or bank account on file, and how to collect the missed payment. For what NextKick does automatically, see How Autopay Works & What Happens When a Payment Fails.

Before you start

Step 1: Find failed charges

  1. In the left sidebar, click Payments → Transaction Errors.

  2. The Payment Error History page lists every failed charge, with the Name, Membership, Last 4 Digits of the card, Error Reason and Error Date.

  3. Use Error Date to choose a date range, or Search Member to find one student. Click Export to download the list.

Each failed attempt is listed separately, so a card that NextKick retries can appear more than once. You can also spot problems from the "!" next to a student's name in Accounts → Profiles, or in Home → Overdue Invoices.

Failed charges don't appear in Payments → Transactions. That page lists payments that are Paid, Processing, Refunded, Partial Refund or Voided.

Step 2: Check the error reason

The Error Reason tells you what to ask the family for. Common reasons:

Error reason

What to do

Expired Card.

Ask the family for a new card.

Invalid card information., Invalid card number. or Invalid expiration date.

The card details on file are wrong. Ask the family to enter the card again.

The card was declined. or The card limit was exceeded.

Ask the family to check with their bank or use another card.

Declined by the card issuer. or declined this payment as suspected fraud

The family needs to call the bank that issued the card.

This card has been closed. or No account exists for this card.

Ask the family for a different card.

The cardholder stopped recurring payments.

The family blocked automatic charges with their bank. Ask them to allow them again or use another card.

Invalid bank account information. or Invalid routing number.

The bank account details are wrong. Ask the family to enter them again. See How to Accept Bank Account (ACH) Payments.

CVV code does not match., CVV mismatch or Incorrect CVV

The security code doesn't match the card. Ask the family to enter the card again, with the correct CVV and ZIP code. If it keeps failing, they should call the bank that issued the card.

CID format error

American Express cards use a 4-digit security code (CID) on the front of the card. Ask the family to enter the card again with all 4 digits.

For failed bank (ACH) payments, also see Why Did a Bank (ACH) Payment Fail? What to Do.

Step 3: Get a working card or bank account

Option A (easiest): send the payment update link. The family enters their own card or bank account and chooses whether to use it for their memberships. If they do, autopay switches to it.

  1. Go to Accounts → Profiles and open the student.

  2. Click Payment Info.

  3. Click Share payment update link, or click Payment Update URL to copy the link and send it yourself.

See How to Send a Payment Update Link. Families can also add a card in the student app. See How Families Update Their Card in the Student App.

Option B: add the card yourself. If the family gives you new card details, for example at the front desk:

  1. Open the student's profile and click Payment Info.

  2. Click Add New Credit Card or Add new bank account.

  3. Enter the details and click Save.

  4. If the student has memberships that pay by card or bank account, a window lists them. Click Apply to Memberships to switch them to the new card, or Not now to keep their current payment method and do it in Step 4.

Step 4: Make the new card the default and apply it to memberships

  1. In Payment Info, click ⋮ next to the new card, then click Set Default.

  2. Click Confirm.

  3. The Set Default Payment Method window lists each membership that will switch to this card, with its next payment date. Click Apply to Memberships.

NextKick confirms how many memberships were updated. Memberships paid by cash, check or In-House Credit Card are listed under Not changed and keep their payment method. If you click Not now instead, the card becomes the default, but the memberships keep charging the old one. If none of the memberships would change, the window doesn't appear.

Step 5: Collect the missed payment

Once a new card is applied to the membership, the next automatic retry charges it. It isn't charged the moment the card is updated. To collect the payment now, or to collect a failed bank (ACH) payment, which isn't retried, charge it yourself:

  1. Go to Home → Overdue Invoices.

  2. Click the invoice.

  3. Click Pay Now.

Before you click Pay Now on a bank payment, check with the family that the account has enough funds. A failed bank payment may cost a fee.

If you don't change anything, NextKick retries a failed card every 2 days, up to 8 attempts in total (about two weeks). Failed bank (ACH) payments aren't retried.

If the membership became inactive

After the 7th failed attempt, NextKick alerts your school. If all 8 attempts fail, the membership becomes inactive and autopay stops. The student's profile can still show Active, so check the membership itself. To get it charging again:

  1. Add a working card or bank account and apply it to the student's memberships (Steps 3 and 4).

  2. Open the student's profile, click the Membership tab, and click Actions → Activate membership on the inactive membership.

  3. Set the next payment date. Pick a future date. The day you pick becomes the monthly billing day from then on.

  4. Check the payment method and Remaining payments. Entering 0 activates the membership without charging the remaining payments.

  5. Click Activate.

Members who share a family membership are set back to active too. Collect the payment that failed with Pay Now on the overdue invoice (Step 5).

FAQ

A parent updated their card, but autopay still charges the old one. Why?

The new card may not be applied to their memberships. Open their Payment Info, click ⋮ next to the new card, click Set Default, and then Apply to Memberships. Then charge the missed payment with Pay Now (Step 5).

Why does the same student appear many times in Transaction Errors?

Every failed attempt is listed, including NextKick's retries of a card every 2 days.

Can I stop the automatic retries?

Yes. On the membership, click Actions → Stop retrying failed payment. This stops the automatic attempts for that billing cycle only. Autopay stays on for future payments, and you need to collect that payment yourself. Pausing the membership also stops the retries, and the invoice stays overdue until you collect it or void it.

Does the family know their payment failed?

Yes. After each failed charge, NextKick sends the family an email, a text and a push notification with a payment update link. See How Autopay Works & What Happens When a Payment Fails.

A family paid at the desk for an overdue invoice. What do I do?

Record the payment on the overdue invoice right away as Cash or Check (use these for Zelle or Venmo too). Otherwise, the automatic retry can still charge the family's card. You can also stop the retries with Actions → Stop retrying failed payment on the membership.

I moved a student's billing day. Why is the failed payment still retrying?

Moving the billing day doesn't move an invoice that already failed. It keeps retrying until it's paid or you click Actions → Stop retrying failed payment.

Why was a second charge on the same card declined as fraud?

Banks may flag back-to-back charges on one card as fraud, for example payments for two siblings. The family should call their bank and ask it to allow the charges. Then collect the payment with Pay Now (Step 5), or let the next automatic retry charge it.

A family sees pending charges after a failed payment. Were they charged?

No. After a failed CVV check, the family's bank may show pending amounts on their statement. These are temporary authorization holds, not charges.

Related articles

Did this answer your question?